Let me start by saying this isn’t even close. I will personally fight anyone who picks A Christmas Story over It’s a Wonderful Life. Seriously, as Machine Gun Kelly says, “text me the addy, I’m pulling up scrappin'”.
I never enjoyed It’s a Wonderful Life as a kid. It was in black and white, it was set in the stone ages – really 1945-, and I didn’t know any of the actors or actresses. Can we still use those terms? Or is it now actperson? As I got older the movie became akin to Angels in the Outfield and I couldn’t get enough. Angels getting wings, angels helping people out, just angels in general. I love the supernatural and paranormal so this was always cool to me. It also holds a special place in my heart as the first movie I can remember that made me cry. George with his hearing loss, George saving another kid from getting poisoned, George’s dad dying of a stroke, George losing the money from the bank, George contemplating suicide, and then finally George coming to terms with reality.
The lesson hits home, especially around the holiday season, family and loved ones mean everything. As Clarence, the guardian angel, inscribes “remember, George: no man is a failure who has friends”. Religion aside, that is the true spirit of Christmas. It is a time of celebration, a time of thankfulness, a time to spend with those closest to you and express how much they mean to you. While the central plot line doesn’t focus around Christmas itself, it focuses around the meaning of Christmas which is even stronger. I also think it is a movie that everyone can relate to. Everyone can relate to a time that they helped someone else, everyone can relate to a time they have had a hardship, everyone can relate to a time they have questioned life, albeit maybe not the extent of suicide.
Not to mention, the movie has withstood the sands of time. Know what other movies came out in 1946? Crack-up, Duel in the Sun, Great Expectations, The Blue Dahlia, Undercurrent. I could keep going on but there will be more movies you’ve never heard of. Great Expectations is known as a novel and the 1946 release of Beauty and the Beast I didn’t know existed until I just googled “1946 movies”.
What It’s a Wonderful Life holds in value A Christmas Story holds in stupidity. It amazes me that a movie so bad can have so many adaptations and memorable quotes. Sure it’s hilarious that Ralphie says fuck and gets his mouth washed out with soap. It’s funny about shooting one’s eye out. It’s funny there is a lamp that looks like a sexy leg. As Andrew says, I think the nostalgia of the movie is ruined by by how much it is shoved down our throats as a society. I can’t look at my Facebook page without someone posting a some news story about the house in Cleveland, how they bought the lamp as a funny joke, a meme about sticking your tongue to a light pole. It has soured the reputation of the movie and is why it won’t last past the first round of cuts. It’s really hard for me to look at this movie and see an underlying theme other than slapstick comedy and a brat of a kid. Listen, I love Harry Potter. I have Daniel Radcliffe tattooed on my damn arm, if I was forced to watch one of the Harry Potter for 24 hours on repeat on TBS I would probably hate that too and seek laser tattoo removal. Other cult classics aren’t even jammed down our throat this much. I think Roger Ebert’s assessment of it only having success because it was a Christmas movie is right. Take Ralphie and have him bitch and moan about Halloween candy and the movie won’t be nearly as successful.
It’s a Wonderful Life over A Christmas Story IN A LANDSLIDE.

